Community Leaders and Scholars Discuss Alternative Strategies for the Drug War

4

EL PASO — While the death-toll rises and fear grips the citizens of the El Paso/Juarez border due to the mounting violence of warring drug cartels, El Paso’s leaders are not resigned to do nothing.

They are urgently seeking solutions, promoting dialogue and evaluating current policies in attempts to unravel the massive drug problem that plagues the country and has devastated the region.

Dr. William Martin (Nora Orozco/Borderzine.com)

Dr. William Martin (Nora Orozco/Borderzine.com)

El Paso is a fertile place for these conversations. Last week, community leaders, scholars and experts from across the country, participated in a University of Texas at El Paso sponsored U.S. War on Drugs conference.

Many attending the conference learned that in the U.S. marijuana was first declared illegal in El Paso in 1914, in what many say was an anti-immigration response to a large influx of immigrants.

“It started here, let’s end it here,” said William Martin, a panelist at the conference and fellow at the Baker Institute and professor of sociology at Rice University, who pointed to the irony of El Paso’s circumstances.

It was also El Paso City Councilman Beto O’Rourke, whose unanimously approved proposal to consider a debate on ending drug prohibition drew a storm of national attention and criticism and a rapid veto from Mayor John Cook. It is only fitting that El Paso continue to be the platform where intellectuals and civic leaders forge the discussion for a situation that has no easy solutions but demands action.

Many believe, that policy is at the heart of the problem. If making marijuana illegal is supposed to make it harder to buy, then why do surveys report that kids find it easier to get marijuana than alcohol?

These are some of the questions that Ethan Nadelmann, founder and executive director of the Drug Policy Alliance, posed in attempts to reform the current 40-year-old policies that he says have only proven to be more fatal and costly.

“If you want to know how to get marijuana, just ask your kids,” said Nadelmann.

In a panel entitled “Alternative Strategies and Policy Proposals for the Drug War,” NPR correspondent John Burnett served as moderator and played devil’s advocate to the representatives who advocated alternative policies from decriminalization to legalization. As a journalist who has interviewed a myriad of officials directly involved in the drug war he told the panel that generally they believed that the premise that we are losing the drug war is erroneous.

Amber Langston, Dr. Ethan Nadelmann, José R. Rodríguez (Nora Orozco/Borderzine.com)

Amber Langston, Dr. Ethan Nadelmann, José R. Rodríguez (Nora Orozco/Borderzine.com)

“It is like saying that because there are still thefts and rapes, the war on crime has been lost and therefore it is hopeless,” said Burnett. These officials maintain that these law enforcement efforts have kept countless quantities of drugs from ever making it to the streets.

Nadelmann responded that although criminalization has deterring benefits, the cost to society in terms of dollars and lives far out weigh the advantages. The black market has fueled the violence in Juarez, he said, the site of more than 3,000 drug related killings in the last two years.

Martin said people think it is the drugs that caused these problems, but he thinks it is the fight over drug trafficking caused by prohibition that did this. “From a prosecutors stand point it doesn’t make sense to do something over and over and over again,“ said Jose Rodriguez, county attorney for El Paso County who prosecutes juvenile crime.

He said the cost of incarceration and prosecution clogs up the judicial system, and the resources that should go to intervention and prevention. He also pointed out inconsistencies of what he called an unfair system. “When you can be prosecuted for a small amount of marijuana but not for being involved in college binge drinking that leads to death,” said Rodriguez, “It is a wrong message to send.”

Amber Langston, outreach director for Students for Sensible Drug Policy, also compares marijuana to alcohol in terms of the effects of the policy. “We don’t put drinkers in prison because we realize that it is futile,” Langston said. “It is not going to help them, or solve any problems.”

Legalizing marijuana is an action that the mayor of Ciudad Juarez is considering as a viable option. Martin holds that legalizing marijuana in Texas would diminish the power of the drug cartels. Reduction measures such as programs like heroine maintenance and development of chemicals for treating the effects and desire of cocaine abuse are currently being developed and should be part of the solution, she said.

Taxation would create the revenue to fund these programs. “But, the idea is to reduce the black market, to discourage consumption, like what we are doing with tobacco,” said Nadelmann. He also praised the efforts of El Pasoans who, he said, have spoken courageously on the topic and provided a role model for democracy.

_____

Borderzine’s sponsor, All About Counseling, recommends the following site for further information on the topic:

Drug addiction counseling

Comments

comments

Share.

4 Comments

  1. Liberty is the only solution to Society’s drug problem. Without liberty to cultivate and share what the earth brings forth, society will continue to suffer the plague of prohibition.

  2. Savastano@gmail.com on

    Solid piece – I think I have taken away some new entries for my own site. Lots of interesting content here. Keep it up.

  3. Jack McGarvey
    Jack from Arizona on

    There is a downside to legalizing marijuana that may cause an even greater flood of the desperate poor trying illegally to cross the border.

    I know, personally, several families living in Sinaloa who are fine, honest, church-going folk who are employed on large marijuana plantations (one, allegedly run by the Mexican Army) doing the complex cultivation, and engaging in processing, packaging, and sometimes transporting the drug. They are paid well – about 4 times as much as they could make working on one of the big farms there.

    Legalize the drug; they are out of work.

    Then again, within a year or so, Archer-Daniel-Midland, Conagra, and R. J. Reynolds will take over the entire business and likely pay its workers the same they pay tomato pickers – which is about $6 US a day.

    I favor legalizing marijuana, but believe that doing so, will curtail illegal immigration is a pipe dream.

    (No, I don’t smoke weed: tried it once – bad trip. Not for me!)

Leave A Reply

Don't miss a thing! Signup here for unique coverage of border life you won't find anywhere else

Join our mailing list to receive weekly news and commentary on Border Life

I am a..

Thank you! You have successfully subscribed.